Dismissal is a false rumor! Sichuan University: Processing result not released from school | Female | Processing result

recently

Guangzhou Metro Line 8

The incident of "Uncle suspected of secretly taking selfies to prove his innocence but still exposed"

Causing attention and discussion among netizens

June 11th

The woman involved publicly apologizes

today

The reporter learned from Sichuan University that:

The school attaches great importance to this matter

Closely contacted the local police

Understand and verify the situation with the students involved

We will handle it in accordance with the procedures, laws, and regulations

For online rumors, the school will expel the girl

Staff from Sichuan University stated that

These rumors are not officially released by the school

The current processing result has not been released yet

Lawyer:

Schools should be cautious in determining disciplinary measures

What legal issues are involved in this incident?

Lawyer Xia Hailong from Shanghai Shenlun Law Firm told reporters that a girl's unauthorized uploading of someone else's video content to the internet and using obvious negative vocabulary to describe without factual basis constitutes an infringement of someone else's reputation and portrait rights. In addition, the public opinion impact brought by such exposure behavior will undoubtedly have a huge impact on the normal private life and peace of the parties involved. From this perspective, the girl's behavior also infringes on the privacy rights of the parties involved.

What kind of punishment may the girl involved face?

The reporter found a copy of the "Disciplinary Regulations for Students at Sichuan University", which states in Chapter 2, Article 5 of "Violation of Discipline and Graduation" that if a student commits any of the following behaviors, they will be expelled from school, including "infringing on the legitimate rights and interests of other individuals or organizations, causing serious consequences"; Article 7 stipulates that those who violate computer network management regulations shall be given the following punishments depending on the severity of the circumstances, including "those who use the internet to openly insult or fabricate facts for defamation shall be given a serious warning until being detained for observation.".

Xia Hailong believes that whether a girl will be expelled is an internal student management matter of the school, which depends on how the student management system of Sichuan University is regulated. He said that expulsion from school is the heaviest punishment for students. Although the girl's behavior carries malicious speculation and has caused a lot of public opinion response, considering that the person involved has expressed forgiveness and she has also been widely criticized by public opinion, the school should carefully determine the punishment measures.

Hu Xijin: Give her a chance

Most netizens: take serious measures

Regarding this girl, former Global Times editor in chief and renowned commentator Hu Xijin posted on June 11th, stating that he understands the anger that everyone continues to criticize that girl. But I still think the public opinion should accept her apology. The uncle and his son in question chose to forgive, demonstrating generosity. We should all adopt the same attitude as Mr. Deng. As Mr. Deng said, after all, she is still a student, and this mistake has had a great impact on her, enough to become a major lesson for her. People usually regret it at such times. In this situation, the public opinion should give this girl a chance together. Everyone makes mistakes, especially young people, and being a good person can be said to be a lifelong learning.

However, this viewpoint has been opposed by many netizens. Therefore, Hu Xijin once again posted on June 12th, stating that he has no intention of deliberately innovating on the issue of this girl, respecting the opinions of netizens, and hoping to express some of his own views. Believe in the ultimate tolerance of diverse public opinion fields towards different opinions.

Hu Xijin believes that most "sincere confessions" and "sincere apologies" in this world are forced to be made, but usually such confessions and apologies are meaningful. They represent the submission to justice, obedience to the law and moral order, and are also a way to understand the current situation, indicating a turning point in a new direction. So, society should encourage the majority of "sincere apologies". If we do not accept any sincere apologies that arise under pressure, it may lead to an escalation of accountability for general errors. Indeed, there are some people who only consider admitting mistakes and apologizing as temporary measures to pass the test and avoid punishment. Such people are prone to falling back in the future, and society will increase punishment based on their criminal record. However, we cannot simply refuse the apology of the offender just because such a situation exists. If we form a strong deterrent force to maintain public order and good customs, and give sincere apologies the opportunity to correct their mistakes, then our society will be both just and powerful, and inclusive.

Although the stigmatized uncle chose to forgive, some netizens believed that the girl should be given a chance to improve, but more netizens believed that this could not be accomplished with just an apology. Uncle and his family were kind and simple, choosing to forgive the woman without pursuing legal responsibility. But the woman is a graduate student studying journalism, and her behavior of maliciously slandering others even after confirming that the other party did not secretly take photos is of a bad nature. The school should take it seriously. As an adult, one should take responsibility for their words and actions. If they make mistakes, they should be punished accordingly. Only with real lessons can they remind them to grow healthier in the future, rather than crying and begging for mercy, hoping to escape the punishment they deserve.