How do you think its level is?, AI Middle School Entrance Exam Same Topic Essay | Fudan MOSS Big Model Writing Middle School Entrance Exam Essay Topic | Joy | Essay

[Editor's note]

On June 17th, 2023, the Shanghai high school entrance examination will begin. The 600 word essay titled "The Joy of Understanding" has once again sparked public interest both inside and outside the candidate's family. Essay questions, whether difficult or not; If it were you, how would you write it?

In this era of booming artificial intelligence, the issue of essay writing in college entrance exams may be approached from a machine perspective. Jiefang Daily · Shangguan News has invited major domestic generative pre training large models to write essays on the same topic on multiple AI platforms, and invited relevant experts from various fields to comment on how these robots understand natural language in the "simulation test". Has the writing skills surprised humans? How exactly is it written? Let's learn and learn from each other.

This morning, the 2023 Shanghai High School Entrance Examination Chinese composition question was unveiled, titled "The Joy of Understanding". Can the artificial intelligence big language model accurately review questions? How is the writing level? The Jiefang Daily Shangguan News reporter inputted the topic into the MOSS large model developed by the research team of Fudan University, which quickly generated an article according to the requirements. Senior Chinese language teachers in middle schools believe that it is generally well written, but lacks genuine emotions and factual evidence to prove the argument. What do you think?

The Joy of Understanding

There are many types of happiness in life, and one of the most special ones is the joy of understanding. The joy of understanding is a kind of spiritual pleasure, a profound resonance, and an indescribable feeling. When we are communicating with others, we suddenly find that they have said what we have always wanted to say, or when we are doing something, we suddenly find that our thoughts coincide with those of others. At this time, we will experience a very pleasant feeling, which is the joy of understanding.

The joy of understanding is not a simple pleasure, it requires us to have a certain ability to think and comprehend. Only when we accumulate certain experience and knowledge in learning and life can we better understand the meaning of others and express our own ideas. Therefore, the joy of understanding is a joy that requires continuous learning and accumulation.

The joy of understanding is also a profound resonance. When we share our experiences and feelings with others, if they can understand our inner world and provide us with support and encouragement, then we will feel a joy of being understood and recognized. This kind of happiness is not only because we have received support and encouragement from others, but more importantly, because we have found someone who is connected to our own soul.

Finally, the joy of understanding is also a feeling of emotional harmony. When we are with close people, we can feel their emotions and thoughts without words. This kind of tacit understanding and emotional connection makes us feel an indescribable joy. This kind of happiness not only makes us feel happy and satisfied, but also makes us feel the meaning and value of life.

In short, the joy of understanding is a very special kind of happiness, which requires us to have a certain ability to think and comprehend, to constantly learn and accumulate, and to establish deep resonance and emotional connections with others. When we experience the joy of understanding, we feel an indescribable happiness and satisfaction, which will become the most precious memory in our lives.

Expert comments

Tao Lu

After reading this essay, I think MOSS is generally well written:

Firstly, the question was thoroughly reviewed, and the basic understanding of the connotation of "the joy of understanding" was expressed in elegant language: "The joy of understanding is a pleasure of the soul, a profound resonance, and an indescribable feeling."

The second is that the discourse is organized. The article adopts a parallel discourse structure and proposes three sub points: the pleasure of understanding requires us to have a certain ability to think and comprehend, which is a profound resonance and a feeling of emotional harmony.

The third concluding point further elaborates on the central idea: "When we experience the joy of understanding, we feel an indescribable happiness and satisfaction, which will become the most precious memory in our lives."

However, according to the grading criteria for high school essays, articles written by MOSS are unlikely to receive high scores. The middle school entrance examination essay is usually a narrative based, interspersed and discussed article, which should reflect the author's true emotions and feelings. The narration should be vivid, and writing techniques such as language description, demeanor description, and psychological description can be used. Rhetoric techniques such as metaphor can also be used.

According to this standard, MOSS is clearly not fully compliant. It is an argumentative essay with little vivid narration, lacking vivid evidence to support the argument, and failing to express its true feelings in the writing.

This flaw is understandable, as MOSS is a machine rather than a human, lacking human emotions and life experiences. Life is the source of composition, and the AI big model lacks the world of life and self-awareness. How can it truly understand the joy of understanding?